Split Residential Electric Rate Classes: Standard & Low Income

by | Sep 22, 2026 | News & Blog

Why Low- and Moderate-Income Advocates Should Weigh In on Hawaiian Electric’s Rebasing Case — and the Rate-Design Options Worth Watching

 

Hawaiian Electric, Hawai’i Electric Light Company, and Maui Electric Company filed a rebasing proposal with the Hawai’i Public Utilities Commission (PUC) on July 17, 2026, asking to raise combined annual revenues by roughly $170 million, or 5.3%, phased in as approximately $125 million effective January 1, 2027 and an additional approximately $45 million effective January 1, 2028.

 

The filing is docketed as Docket No. 2026-0162, and the PUC has scheduled public hearings across the islands — Hawai’i Island (Kona, Sept. 22; Hilo, Sept. 24), Maui (Sept. 29), Lāna’i (Sept. 30), Moloka’i (Oct. 1), and O’ahu (Oct. 2) — along with an open written-comment period (Hawai’i PUC public notice).

 

It’s worth being precise about what this docket actually decides, and when, because that precision matters for anyone deciding whether — and how — to get involved.

 

What Docket 2026-0162 Is — and How It’s Structured

 

Docket No. 2026-0162 is the Companies’ rebasing case, and the PUC has structured it as a single proceeding split into two sequential tracks.

 

Track 1 addresses “modifications to Target Revenue for each of the Companies to begin MRP2” — i.e., the overall revenue requirement. This is the $170 million, 5.3% figure now moving through public hearings, with a final Track 1 decision expected around mid-to-late April 2027.

 

Track 2, per Order No. 41575 at 33-34, will “focus on updating revenue allocation and rate design for each of the Companies in accordance with updated class load information and cost-of-service analysis” — the question of how the approved revenue requirement gets divided among residential, commercial, and industrial classes, and where any LMI-specific rate structure would be decided.

 

The Companies’ estimated bill impacts, once both revenue phases take effect, are approximately $11/month on O’ahu, $15/month on Hawai’i Island, $14/month on Maui, and $11/month on Moloka’i and Lāna’i for a typical residential customer under current rate design — figures the Companies calculate using 500 kWh per month, or 400 kWh on Lāna’i and Moloka’i, a level many LMI households fall below. Those figures will be revisited once Track 2 reallocates costs among classes.

 

This two-track structure is the reason LMI community groups have a genuine stake in this docket, not just the current public-hearing phase on Track 1.

 

Track 2 — where rate design and cost-of-service allocation will actually be decided — has not yet concluded, and the Commission has signaled it wants a complete rate design proposal informed by updated class load studies. That makes now the right time for LMI advocates to begin building the evidentiary record and intervention posture for Track 2, even while Track 1’s hearings are still underway. How a group gets standing depends on whether it is already in the PBR docket.

 

Order No. 42639 provides that all parties to Docket No. 2018-0088 are automatically named as parties to the rebasing proceeding without the need to move for intervention — with one carve-out, the City and County of Honolulu, which the Commission excluded from automatic party status and which must move to intervene or participate like any new entity. The existing intervenors carried over include Blue Planet Foundation, Life of the Land, Hawaiʻi PV Coalition, Hawaiʻi Solar Energy Association, Ulupono Initiative and the County of Hawaiʻi, alongside the Companies and the Consumer Advocate as an ex officio party.

 

An LMI organization that is not already a party to Docket No. 2018-0088 has no automatic standing and must file a motion to intervene or participate in Docket No. 2026-0162. The tentative Track 1 schedule in Order No. 42639 runs from the new application through public hearings to an evidentiary hearing in late February 2027 — estimated at three to four days in panel format, and subject to waiver — post-hearing briefs in mid-March 2027, a final Track 1 decision and order in mid-to-late April 2027, and a Commission order initiating Track 2 subsequent to the Track 1 decision.

 

The order also requires Hawaiian Electric to respond to each information request within five business days absent leave from the Commission. The Commission stated it would affirm a fuller schedule once the new application was filed, while not expecting the structure to change.

 

Why LMI Participation Matters Regardless of Docket Boundaries

 

Traditional utility rate design in Hawai’i, as elsewhere, groups most residential customers into a single class — Schedule R for Hawaiian Electric — under cost-of-service principles that spread fixed and variable costs relatively uniformly across all residential accounts. That approach was designed for administrative simplicity and to avoid “undue discrimination” among customers of the same class, but it also means LMI households, who spend a disproportionate share of income on energy, absorb the same fixed monthly charges and volumetric rate structure as higher-income households in the same class.

 

A growing number of regulators around the country are testing whether structural separation of LMI accounts — not just bill-assistance programs layered on top of a uniform rate — can better address energy burden. Three examples illustrate the range of approaches, though they differ significantly in how far each has gone toward truly separate rate classes.

 

California: Income-Graduated Fixed Charges

 

Following state legislation (AB 205, 2022) directing a restructuring of fixed charges, the California Public Utilities Commission required the state’s investor-owned utilities to shift part of the fixed-charge portion of residential bills onto an income-graduated basis, with a corresponding reduction in volumetric rates (CPUC Demand Flexibility Rulemaking filing).

 

The adopting order is CPUC Decision No. 24-05-028, issued May 2024 in the Demand Flexibility Rulemaking, R.22-07-005, Track A. In practice, this creates income-based tiers within the standard residential class: CARE-eligible and other lower-income tiers pay a smaller fixed charge than higher-income customers, even though everyone remains formally within the same residential rate schedule.

 

AB 1999 (2023-24), which would have capped the fixed charge and made the income-graduated authority inoperative on July 1, 2028, failed — it died in the Assembly and never became law. The income-graduated structure therefore remains in place, now generally referred to as the Base Services Charge, with CPUC implementation and income-verification working groups still active in 2026. The episode is nonetheless a reminder that this is an actively contested and evolving policy, not a settled national model.

 

Maryland: The Limited Income Mechanism

 

The Maryland Public Service Commission issued Order No. 92190 on February 12, 2026 (Administrative Docket PC 59, “Order on Limited Income Mechanism”) directing utilities to develop discounted-rate systems for qualifying limited-income customers under Maryland Public Utilities Article § 4-309, intended to correlate what customers pay more closely with ability to pay (Maryland PSC order; Maryland PSC press release).

 

The Commission stated its intent that the mechanism be implemented prior to January 1, 2027 — a target, not a fixed statutory effective date — with proposed marketing materials in summer 2026 and proposed tariffs in fall 2026, and the PC 59 work group continuing as Phase II.

 

The order is also more prescriptive than a set of general guidelines: it approves a tiered mechanism keyed to Office of Home Energy Programs poverty levels and heating source, makes customers at OHEP Poverty Level 6 and below eligible year-round, computes an annual average credit against a target energy-burden threshold, splits the burden goal evenly between gas and electric bills for dual-fuel customers, and requires a percentage-of-rate discount for all utilities except SMECO, which may use a flat bill credit.

 

New York: Program Separation, Short of a Distinct Rate Class

 

New York is sometimes cited as a model for LMI rate segmentation, but the record needs a more careful description.

 

In the long-running Case 14-M-0565 proceeding on energy affordability, the Public Utility Law Project of New York (PULP) has pushed the NYPSC to keep the existing low-income Energy Affordability Program (EAP) — which already provides bill discounts targeting the 6%-of-income energy-burden threshold adopted in the NYPSC’s Order Adopting Low Income Program Modifications (Case 14-M-0565, issued May 20, 2016), and which the Commission has since supplemented with an Energy Affordability Guarantee Pilot (order issued Aug. 15, 2024) — administratively and financially separate from a newer “enhanced” or moderate-income affordability program, so that expanding assistance to moderate-income households doesn’t dilute funding or eligibility protections for the lowest-income participants (NY DPS Case 14-M-0565 filings).

 

That is a real and consequential fight over how affordability program budgets and eligibility rules are structured. It is not, based on the documents reviewed, a petition for a formally separate residential rate class with its own tailored green-rate or volumetric design — the EAP operates as a bill discount layered onto the standard rate schedule, not a distinct tariff class.

 

Readers should treat New York as an example of hard-fought program-level separation rather than rate-class separation, and verify the current docket record directly if citing it as precedent for a class-based approach.

 

How Structural Separation Changes What’s Possible

 

The reason class or sub-class separation matters — where it has actually been implemented, as in California’s income-graduated tiers or Maryland’s limited-income mechanism — is that it can unlock ratemaking tools that would otherwise risk violating “undue discrimination” principles if applied selectively within a single uniform class:

 

Flat or capped affordability rates, designed around a defined affordable-energy-burden percentage, with the unrecovered revenue requirement shifted to other rate tiers.

 

Relief from high fixed monthly charges, which disproportionately burden low-use, low-income households regardless of how little electricity they consume.

 

Whether any version of this is appropriate for Hawai’i — and, if so, which docket is the right venue to propose it — is an open question. Hawai’i already has LMI-specific mechanisms outside the standard residential rate class, including LIHEAP-linked bill assistance, the Green Infrastructure Authority’s GEM$ on-bill financing program for LMI solar and efficiency upgrades, and LMI-specific provisions in the Community-Based Renewable Energy tariff docket, Docket No. 2015-0389, established pursuant to Act 100, Session Laws of Hawai’i 2015 (Hawai’i PUC FAQ; PUC Energy Equity and Justice report).

 

The PUC’s Energy Equity and Justice docket (Docket No. 2022-0250), opened in December 2022 in response to legislative resolutions, was explicitly intended to explore “a specific rate or program for LMI customers to reduce disconnections and debts” as one of its workstreams (PUC Workplan Meeting slides, July 2023). However, the Commission’s own docket page shows the last decision and order in the proceeding as Decision and Order No. 40290 (Sept. 27, 2023, setting next steps), with subsequent activity limited to a Jan. 28, 2025 letter noticing selection of an outreach consultant and a Mar. 5, 2025 virtual meeting on disconnections; no 2026 activity is listed.

 

Ililani Media has characterized the docket as “open in name only,” with no substantive action “in years” (Ililani Media on HECO’s Integrated Grid Planning update).

 

That stalled history is itself an argument for LMI community groups to engage now, and specifically in Docket No. 2026-0162: Track 1 sets the revenue baseline that’s currently in public hearings, and the not-yet-concluded Track 2 is where the Companies are to file a complete rate design proposal, which the Commission expects will be supported by class load studies and cost-of-service analyses — the exact juncture at which an LMI rate class or sub-class argument would need to be raised. The long-dormant Energy Equity docket (2022-0250) remains a parallel, PUC-stated venue for the LMI-specific rate or program question, but given its inactivity, Track 2 of 2026-0162 may be the more live and consequential venue in the near term.

 

Sitting out Track 2 risks leaving class-level cost allocation and rate design to be decided without LMI input. Two features of this docket sharpen that risk.

 

First, the proposal reaches the Commission as a joint filing by the utility and one intervenor, Ulupono Initiative, developed through a PBR working group whose other participants included the Consumer Advocate, County of Hawai`i, Blue Planet Foundation, Life of the Land and solar industry organizations — so the record already contains a negotiated position that no party has been required to defend as a contested revenue requirement.

 

Second, the joint proposal drew opposing statements of position in the PBR docket: Life of the Land filed a Statement of Position opposing the Joint Alternative Rebasing Proposal on March 9, 2026, and Blue Planet Foundation filed its own Statement of Position on March 16, 2026. The range under consideration is therefore contested rather than agreed.

 

The Bottom Line

 

Docket No. 2026-0162 is not just a revenue-requirement case — it is explicitly structured to reach rate design and cost-of-service allocation in its Track 2 phase, per PUC Order No. 41575 and PUC Order No. 42639. LMI advocates have a real and time-sensitive opportunity to weigh in now, during Track 1’s public hearings, on the size of the revenue requirement; and an equally important, still-open opportunity to shape

 

Track 2, where class load studies and rate design will determine whether Hawai’i adopts anything resembling California’s income-graduated tiers or Maryland’s limited-income mechanism for LMI customers.

 

Ulupono Initiative and Hawaiian Electric each moved for reconsideration or clarification of Order No. 42639 on June 25 and June 26, 2026; the Commission solicited responses through July 10, 2026 by Order No. 42739, and the Consumer Advocate, Blue Planet Foundation, Life of the Land, the Hawaiʻi Solar Energy Association and the Hawaiʻi PV Coalition all filed. No order resolving those motions appears in the Docket No. 2018-0088 filing record through Sept. 15, 2026, so aspects of the framework described here may yet change.

 

#      #      #